[Dialogue] Anarchism, Hollywood-Style

Mon Mar 20 00:38:58 EST 2006

Ah yes, BuSab.  The issue they were dealing with was fast, very fast  
bureaucray.  BuSab's role was to slow the wheels down...

David Jago
Brisbane, Qld.
On 20 Mar 2006, at 09:46, opossum2 at att.net wrote:

> Harry,
>
>
> This take on anarchism, subversive terrorism, or whatever you call  
> it, got me thinking along a tangent to a short novel by Frank  
> Herbert (of "Dune" fame) called "Whipping Star".  In this  
> futuristic vision, the government is so huge, bureaucratic and all- 
> controlling that there exists, as part of the government, a "Bureau  
> of Sabotage" whose charter is to do exactly that - commit acts of  
> sabotage that will keep some kind of tension going in society.  The  
> more I look around me these days, I'm not sure we are too far from  
> that.
>
>
> Thanks for the posting, as usual.
>
>
> Steve Rhea
>
> Houston, Tx.
>
>
>
> -------------- Original message from "Harry Wainwright" <h- 
> wainwright at charter.net>: --------------
>
> <mime-attachment.gif>
>
> Anarchism, Hollywood-Style
>
> By Anthony Kaufman, AlterNet
> Posted on March 17, 2006, Printed on March 19, 2006
> http://www.alternet.org/story/33579/
>
> If Andy and Larry Wachowski's "The Matrix" trilogy turned millions  
> of Americans on to cyberpunk culture and postmodern theory, then "V  
> for Vendetta," the brothers' latest project (which opens today),  
> might just do the same for out-and-out revolution.
>
> Conceived by the Wachowskis and directed by their longtime  
> assistant director James McTeigue, "Vendetta" is a pop-culture  
> attack on the current administration's multiple injustices -- a big- 
> budget call to rebellion from deep inside the belly of conglomerate  
> Time Warner. Warner Bros.' film unit already got flack from  
> conservatives for releasing "Syriana," "Good Night and Good Luck"  
> and Palestinian suicide-bomber portrait "Paradise Now," but just  
> you wait: "V for Vendetta" is a pro-revolutionary action-adventure  
> romp that makes those films look like "Little House on the Prairie."
>
> In perhaps the most glaring and controversial example of  
> Hollywood's refusal to toe the Bush party line, "Vendetta's" hero  
> is a terrorist -- a violent rebel on a mission to destroy his  
> corrupt government in a blaze of explosives. Is this irresponsible?  
> Does it glamorize terrorism? Perhaps. But for many progressives,  
> whose anti-war protests have fallen on deaf ears and whose activism  
> has been squashed by the powers-that-be, "V for Vendetta" should  
> feel almost cathartic.
>
> Set in the year 2020, "V for Vendetta" takes place in a fascistic  
> London, some time after "America's war grew worse and worse," as  
> one character narrates, "when unfamiliar words like 'collateral'  
> and 'rendition' became frightening." The government is a cross  
> between a full-blown totalitarian state and the current  
> administration's scare tactics: with constant surveillance, a  
> citywide "yellow-coded curfew" that instills paranoia and restricts  
> nighttime movement, and a menacing band of secret police called  
> "Fingermen" who patrol the streets and harass the citizens.
>
> When we first meet Evey Hammond (Natalie Portman), she's about to  
> pay the price for violating the city curfew when a mysterious  
> masked stranger saves her from the authorities with an array of  
> flying swords. Evey's savior is V, an erudite, Shakespeare-quoting  
> burn victim who has literally adopted both the mask and the mission  
> of long-ago subversive Guy Fawkes, who in 1605 plotted to destroy  
> Parliament with 36 barrels of gunpowder. With the help of the  
> young, pretty Evey (the daughter of "activist" parents abducted and  
> killed by the government), V plans to carry out Fawkes' dreams of  
> violent insurrection. "Blowing up a building," he tells her, "can  
> change the world."
>
> If there's any question about the film's political targets,  
> "Vendetta" opens with a ridiculously racist and homophobic screed  
> by Prothero, the Bill O'Reilly-like "Voice of London" who speaks on  
> what appears to be the country's only television channel. "The  
> former United States is the world's biggest leper colony," he  
> spits. "And it wasn't because of the immigrants, the Muslims or the  
> homosexuals, or the war that they started. No," he says. "It's  
> because they're Godless!"
>
> In contrast to Edward R. Murrow's famous signoff of "Good night and  
> good luck," the nasty Prothero ends his ultraconservative  
> broadcasts with the jingoistic "England prevails."
>
> This isn't subtle stuff. In a blatant nod to George Orwell's  
> "1984," "Vendetta's" U.K. is ruled by Chancellor Sutler, a  
> vituperative, "deeply religious conservative" seen Big Brother-like  
> on a large television screen (and played by John Hurt, "1984's" ill- 
> fated everyman). Sutler's ruling philosophy is the politics of  
> fear. "We will show him what terror really looks like," he screams  
> after V's arrival onto the scene.
>
> Sutler's reign also involves media spin and propaganda, a la the  
> Newspeak of "1984." When events begin to spiral out of control,  
> Sutler declares that the government must make the people realize  
> "why they need us," followed by panic-inducing reports of  
> everything from civil war to avian flu. Sound familiar?
>
> Like any classic comic superhero myth, "Vendetta" also provides an  
> origin story for V, which is gradually glimpsed in flashbacks and a  
> police investigation into his past. And not unlike the secret  
> nuclear-testing that spawned Godzilla, or the class oppression that  
> cultivated so many angry inner-city zombies (see "Land of the  
> Dead"), V's transformation into a vengeful killer was the result of  
> a crass abuse of state power involving (spoiler alert) a government  
> plan to create a biological weapon with the help of a nefarious  
> pharmaceutical company. If the political notion of "blowback" ever  
> needed a poster child, V would be it.
>
> And "V for Vendetta" isn't just about political revolt -- it's also  
> about sexual revolution. After being captured and placed in an  
> interrogation cell, Evey reads letters from a fellow prisoner,  
> Valerie, a young woman who came out of the closet and embraced a  
> forbidden lesbian love affair that landed her and her lover in  
> similarly brutal confines. Another sympathetic character conceals  
> his homosexual identity. And however ruthless V may be, he too is  
> sexually ambiguous -- an effete hero who hides behind a mask, loves  
> "The Count of Monte Cristo," melancholy music, cooking and dancing  
> ("A revolution without dancing is a revolution not worth having,"  
> he tells Evey, paraphrasing the slogan of anarchist Emma Goldman as  
> he yearns for a whirl).
>
> The movie's sexual politics are also brought to the fore in a  
> quotation heard over the end-credit music: "This is no simple  
> reform," a woman says. "It really is a revolution. Sex and race,  
> because they are easy and visible differences, have been the  
> primary ways of organizing human beings into superior and inferior  
> groups and into the cheap labor in which this system still  
> depends." The voice belongs to feminist powerhouse Gloria Steinem.
>
> Above all, "Vendetta" should be enjoyed as the first true anarchist  
> movie Hollywood has ever made. Film historians speak fondly of the  
> paranoid cycle of American cinema in the 1960s and '70s ("The  
> Manchurian Candidate," "Three Days of the Condor," "The Parallax  
> View") or the countercultural anti-heroic outlaws of "Bonnie and  
> Clyde" and "Badlands," but nowhere in mainstream U.S. cinema -- and  
> certainly not post-9/11 -- has there been a pop-culture phenomenon  
> that advocates not only overthrowing a corrupt government, but  
> blowing it up. As the film's tagline states, "People should not be  
> afraid of their governments. Governments should be afraid of their  
> people."
>
> Anthony Kaufman has written about films and the film industry for  
> the New York Times, the Chicago Tribune and Utne magazine.
>
> © 2006 Independent Media Institute. All rights reserved.
> View this story online at: http://www.alternet.org/story/33579/
>
>
>
> <mime-attachment.gif>
>
> From: "Harry Wainwright" <h-wainwright at charter.net>
> Date: 20 March 2006 05:05:47 GMT+10:00
> To: "'Colleague Dialogue'" <Dialogue at wedgeblade.net>
> Subject: [Dialogue] Anarchism, Hollywood-Style
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> Dialogue mailing list
> Dialogue at wedgeblade.net
> http://wedgeblade.net/mailman/listinfo/dialogue_wedgeblade.net
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> Dialogue mailing list
> Dialogue at wedgeblade.net
> http://wedgeblade.net/mailman/listinfo/dialogue_wedgeblade.net