[Dialogue] Hamas bans Palestinian folk tales book from schools

[Harry Wainwright]

w w w . h a a r e t z . c o m



Last update - 20:52 05/03/2007

Hamas bans Palestinian folk tales book from schools

By The Associated Press


The Hamas-run Education Ministry has ordered an anthology of Palestinian
folk tales pulled from school libraries and destroyed because of sexually
explicit language, officials said Monday, in what critics charged was the
most direct attempt by the Islamic militants to impose their beliefs on
Palestinian society.

The book ban angered and worried many Palestinians, who long feared that
Hamas would use its victory in last year's parliamentary election to remake
the Palestinian territories according to its hard-line interpretation of
Islam.

The 400-page anthology of folk tales narrated by Palestinian women was first
published in English in 1989 by the University of California at Berkeley. It
was put together by Sharif Kanaana, a novelist and anthropology professor at
the West Bank's Bir Zeit University, and by Ibrahim Muhawi, a teacher of
Arabic literature and the theory of translation.

Kanaana said he believes The Little Bird, a tale in a chapter titled Sexual
awakening and courtship, was one of the reasons the book was banned because
it mentions genitals. In their notes, the authors explain that the bird in
the story is a symbol of femininity adding that the use of sexual subjects
in Palestinian folklore is a principal source of humor.

West Bank novelist Zakariya Mohammed said he feared Hamas' decision to ban
Speak Bird, Speak Again, a collection of 45 folk tales, was only the
beginning and urged intellectuals to take action. If we don't stand up to
the Islamists now, they won't stop confiscating books, songs and folklore,
he said.

Education Minister Nasser Shaer confirmed to the AP that the ministry
ordered the book pulled from the school libraries, saying it is full of
clear sexual expressions. However, Shaer denied the books were destroyed.

A senior ministry official, speaking on condition of anonymity because he
was not authorized to discuss the issue with reporters, confirmed that 1,500
copies of the book had been removed from school libraries and destroyed.

Hanan Ashrawi, an independent lawmaker and former Cabinet minister, said the
decision to pull the book was outrageous.

If this is what is to come, it is extremely alarming, she said.

With Hamas slated to retain the Education Ministry under a power-sharing
agreement with the more secular Fatah Party, Ashrawi called for the creation
of an independent body to deal with issues related to arts and education.

Education and culture and social issues should not be handled by anybody
that has a closed, ideological, doctrinal attitude, she said. It should be
in the hands of professionals.

Since taking office last year, Hamas, which advocates an Islamic Palestinian
state, has largely shied away from trying to force its mores on Palestinian
society, despite the fears of rights activists. Some analysts speculated
that the group was too busy dealing with international sanctions and keep
its government from collapsing to focus on banning alcohol or other similar
measures.

However, in recent months the Hamas-controlled ministries have begun forcing
women to don headscarves to enter. And two years ago, Hamas officials in
charge of the West Bank town of Qalqiliya sparked fears of a culture
crackdown by banning a local music festival, arguing that the mingling of
men and women at such an event was haram, or forbidden by Islam.

In a letter sent to the Nablus school district last month, the Education
Ministry said Speak Bird, Speak Again must be removed within a week, and
asked school officials to notify the ministry once they had complied. The
letter did not explain why the book was considered objectionable. 

Excerpts of the letter were read to The Associated Press by a Nablus school
official who spoke on condition of anonymity, for fear of retribution.

After the original English book, a French version, published by UNESCO,
followed in 1997, and an Arabic one in 2001, said Kanaana, who lives in the
West Bank city of Ramallah. At the time of the first publication in Arabic, 
the Palestinian Culture Ministry requested 3,000 copies and had them
distributed in schools, Kanaana said Monday.

Kanaana said that another of the 45 tales also contained what some might
consider vague sexual innuendo, referring to body parts in colloquial
Arabic. 

This is our heritage, this is our life, he said of the folk tales.

One of Kanaana's neighbors, pharmacist Nabil Nahas, 60, said the book was a
treasure, and he was deeply upset by what he said was a Hamas attempt to
silence other opinions.

The author said the stories shouldn't be altered, because this was how they
were transmitted from generation to generation. He didn't mind having a
revised version for young children, but the original should be freely
available, as a historic record, he said.

It's not their right to judge this book, Kanaana said. It's a scientific,
academic book.

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://wedgeblade.net/pipermail/dialogue_wedgeblade.net/attachments/20070305/9b30deda/attachment.html 
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: not available
Type: image/gif
Size: 73 bytes
Desc: not available
Url : http://wedgeblade.net/pipermail/dialogue_wedgeblade.net/attachments/20070305/9b30deda/attachment.gif 
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: not available
Type: image/gif
Size: 73 bytes
Desc: not available
Url : http://wedgeblade.net/pipermail/dialogue_wedgeblade.net/attachments/20070305/9b30deda/attachment-0001.gif